With the president proposing his Fiscal Year 2012 (FY12) budget Monday, February 14, Congress is making its proposals for how to resolve the FY11 budget. Keith Crank and I plan to report the FY12 proposals here in the ASA community:
As a recap on the status of the FY11 budgets, the federal government is operating on a continuing resolution (CR) through April 15. Under the CR, the federal government is (mostly) operating under its FY10 budget. A budget deal appears to be in hand:
FY11 Budget Deal: Impacts on Science and Statistical Agency Budgets.
As most know, the House has pledged to roll the FY11 budget back to the FY08 budget levels, creating the potential for huge cuts to science budgets. The House proposed its first round of cuts to reach the FY08 levels. Meanwhile, the president has been highlighting the importance of research investment as part of his broader innovation push.
In the first draft of the House CR for the rest of FY11 -- keeping in mind that conservative Republicans have said the first draft doesn't go far enough -- NIH would stay at its FY10 level and NSF would see a 6% increase over the FY10 budget (because the proposed cuts are relative to the FY11 requested level.) The Department of Energy Office of Science and NIST would see steep cuts: 18% and 14%, respectively.
H.R. 1, the second draft of the House cuts passed February 19 (and that the Senate rejected in early March), contained 5% cuts for NSF and NIH, along with cuts to the Census Bureau and the Energy Information Administration:
As I said in my
previous blog on how science will fare in the new congress, "
the scientific community must remind returning members of Congress that investment in basic science is critical to American competitiveness and educate the new Members of Congress of the same."
Links to FY11 and FY12 budget developments and related material:
- "How will basic research funding fare in the next Congress?" My previous blog has many links from November through January on the budget developments and outlooks, along with links to making the case for science investment.
- "House to vote early on stopgap funding bill," The Hill, 1/25.
- President Obama's State of the Union (SOTU) Address, "Winning the Future"
- "President Highlights Innovation and Education in His State of the Union," FYI: The AIP Bulletin of Science Policy News
- House Science and Technology Committee's Chair's response to SOTU address
- "Danger: America Is Losing Its Edge In Innovation," 1/20 Forbes piece by Norm Augustine
- "House GOP Proposes Cuts to Scores of Sacred Cows," 2/9 National Journal piece
- "CR Spending Cuts to Go Deep," 2/9 House Appropriations Committee press release listing proposed cuts (relative to FY11 request levels) to 70 programs.
- "GOP cuts deep as right revolts," 2/10 Politico piece
- "Rogers Announces Intent to Cut $100 Billion in the Continuing Resolution," 2/10 House Appropriations Committee press release
- "House Republicans Propose New FY 2011 S&T Budgets," FYI: The AIP Bulletin of Science Policy News
- "Senior House Republican [Majority Leader Cantor] on Competitiveness," FYI: The AIP Bulletin of Science Policy News
- Watch here for further updates, which I'll denote by starting the bullet with the date I post the update.
- 2/12/11: "Congressional Reaction to Proposed Spending Changes," FYI: The AIP Bulletin of Science Policy News
- 2/12/11: "US science agencies targeted for cuts," 2/10/11 Nature piece.
- 2/12/11: "House Panel to Take Second Bite Out of Science Budgets," 2/10/11 Science piece.
- 2/12/11: "House Appropriations Committee Introduces CR Containing Largest Spending Cuts in History," 2/11 House Appropriations Committee press release. Initial indications are that NSF would now see a 5% cut from the FY10 level in this House proposal.
- 2/14/11: FY2012 Budget Request
- 2/14/11: "“R&D Dashboard” Makes Federal R&D Data Transparent and Accessible," 2/10 OSTP Blog by Kei Koizumi
- 2/15/11: "Cut and Grow, Democratic Edition: Obama’s budget makes cuts but calls for investment," 2/14 National Journal piece.
- 2/15/11: "Rethinking Budget Cutting: Fewer Want Spending to Grow, But Most Cuts Remain Unpopular," 2/10 Pew Research release.
- 2/16/11: "Obama asks for science boost; Republicans look for cuts," 2/16 Washington Post piece.
- 2/25/11: "Senate leader to offer 30-day stopgap spending measure," by National Journal's Dan Friedman.
- 2/25/11: "FY 2012 STEM Education Budget Request," FYI: The AIP Bulletin of Science Policy News.
- 2/25/11: "FY 2012 National Science Foundation Budget Request," FYI: The AIP Bulletin of Science Policy News
- 2/25/11: "Sustaining the Commitment: FY 2012 Request Keeps Budget Doubling on Track for NSF, DOE Science, and NIST Research," FYI: The AIP Bulletin of Science Policy News
- 2/25/11: "Can Obama Strike a Deal With House Republicans?," a 2/4 Science piece.
- 2/25/11: House-passed H.R. 1 would cut FY11 budget for NSF and NIH by 5% each.
- 2/25/11: "Continuing Resolution Unveiled Today Will Continue Government Operations, Cut Spending," a 2/25 House Appropriations Committee press release about short term CR. Doesn't seem to contain cuts to NSF or NIH.
- 2/28/11: "Research Vital to Economic Growth," Science Express editorial by former DOE Under Secretary for Science (under George W Bush)
- 2/28/11: "What's lost in the House budget cuts," Washington Post piece on cuts to Science and Census Bureau in H.R. 1.
- 2/28/11: "Sputnikonomics," a 2/14 New Yorker piece by James Surowiecki.
- 3/1/11: "How America can regain its edge," NBC Nightly News, 2/28/11.
- 3/1/11: Science magazine's ScienceInsider piece, "The U.S. Science Budget"
- 3/1/11: "Obama's 2012 Vision Clashes With House Cuts in 2011," a 2/18 Science magazine piece.
- 3/1/11: "Short Term Funding Compromise at Hand, Long Term Conflict Unresolved," FYI: The AIP Bulletin of Science Policy News.
- 3/3/11: "GOP Budget Torches America’s ‘Seed Corn’," Mort Kondracke column in Roll Call.
- 3/3/11: "Proposed budget cuts target science and research," USA Today piece by Dan Vergano.
- 3/3/11: Letter from Task Force on American Innovation to Senate Leaders Reid and McConnell urging they reject House cuts to NSF and other science and STEM education budgets. ASA is one of the signers.
- 3/4/11: "White House agrees to $6.5B more in budget cuts," An AP news story.
- 3/4/11: "U.S. financial health dependent on fiscal discipline," The Hill op-ed by IBM executive Christopher Padilla.
- 3/8/11: Senate releases highlights its version of FY11 CR on 3/4. If enacted, NIH would see its budget held at FY10 levels and NSF would be funded at $6.8 billion (7.7% below the FY11 request and 1% below FY10 ). The Census Bureau would be $44 million below FY11 request.
- 3/8/11: "America's grim budget outlook," a 3/7/11 Washington Post column by Fareed Zakaria about investments to create "the next generation of growth for the next generation of Americans."
- 3/8/11: "IBM’s Watson Serves as Inspiration, Warning," a Roll Call op-ed by Congressman Rush Holt and IBM Executive Christopher Padilla.
- 3/10/11: "Senate rejects spending bills from both Republicans and Democrats," Washington Post story on Senate's defeat of both House H.R. 1 and Senate Appropriations Committee continuing resolution (CR) proposal. (See first 3/8/11 entry three bullets above for more on CR.)
- 3/11/11: "Appropriations Committee Introduces Three Week Continuing Resolution – Bill will Prevent Government Shutdown, Cut $6 Billion in Spending," a 3/11 House Appropriations Committee press release about short term CR. Doesn't seem to contain cuts to NSF or NIH, or any statistical agency.
- 3/11/11: "Important Budget Hearing for the National Science Foundation," FYI: The AIP Bulletin of Science Policy News.
- 3/14/11: See 3/11/11 testimony by Andrew Reamer in support of FY12 budgets for Census Bureau, Bureau of Economic Analysis and NSF NCSES before the House Commerce, Science and Justice Appropriations Subcommittee.
- 3/14/11: See 3/11/11 testimony by Howard Silver (COSSA) in support of FY12 budgets for NSF, BJS and NIJ before the House Commerce, Science and Justice Appropriations Subcommittee.
- 3/17/11: "Riding the innovation wave: To succeed, US must continue to invest in education, research," a 3/14/11 Boston Globe op-ed by the presidents of Harvard and MIT.
- 3/21/11: "Senate Passes Three-Week CR," Senate Appropriations Committee press release. Federal Government now funded through April 8.
- 3/21/11: Online petition opposing NIH funding ASA members urged to sign.
- 3/22/11: American Mathematical Association congressional testimony in support of FY12 NSF budget
- 3/22/11: Mathematical Association of America congressional testimony in support of FY12 NSF budget
- 3/22/11: NSF Research to Jobs document, Provides examples of how NSF research has contributed to job creation and economic growth through new companies.
- 3/31/11: "Business, Science, Engineering and University Leaders Urge Tough Choices on the National Deficit," an Association of Public and Land-grant Universities' press release.
- 3/31/11: "Republicans and Democrats begin negotiating possible budget agreement," a Washington Post piece on FY11 budget negotiations.
- 4/4/11: "Academic and Business Associations Express Concern About Science Funding and Call for Entitlement Reform," FYI: The AIP Bulletin of Science Policy News.
- 4/4/11: COSSA issues Proposed FY 2012 Budgets For Social and Behavioral Science 4/4/11 document, “Winning the Future Amidst a Mountain of Debt”
- 4/5/11: "Another Continuing Resolution Introduced to Prevent Government Shutdown, Cut $12 billion in Spending," 4/4/11 House Appropriations Committee press release. This CR includes a $22 million cut for the Census Bureau but doesn't contain cuts for NIH or NSF. The press release doesn't mention cuts to other statistical agencies but may not cover those kinds of details.
- 4/8/11: "The China Innovation Advantage Act of 2011," Politico op-ed by Nobelist Burton Richter.
- 4/8/11: "House's Science Cuts Threaten Our Future," Huffington Post op-ed by former presidential science advisor Jack Marburger.
- 4/11/11: "Details of the Bipartisan Budget Deal," 4/9 White House blog giving broad sketch of FY11 budget deal:
- "We protected funding for critical programs that invest in science programs, our kids’ education, and critical health programs."
- "we will no longer double the funding of key research and development agencies"
- "you will still see strong investments in National Institute of Standards
and Technology, National Science Foundation and the Office of Science"
- "We were able to avoid making than $500 million cut in lifesaving biomedical research at National Institutes of Health."
- "House Budget Plan Would Cut FY 2012 Science Funding to 2008 Level," FYI: The AIP Bulletin of Science Policy News.
- "Filling the Science Pipeline," a 4/7/11 Roll Call piece.