One moment, processing...
Login to see members-only content.
Blogs & Libraries
My Community Subscriptions
My Privacy Settings
My Contact Requests
My RSS Feeds
My Discussion Postings
My Favorite Documents
Join a Community
Search All Communities
Find a Member
Create New Blog
Share a File
Ask a Question
Create a Blog
Add a New Blog
House Panel holds hearing on making American Community Survey voluntary
The House Oversight and Government Reform Subcommittee on Health Care, District of Columbia, Census and the National Archives held a hearing on March 6, titled "
The Pros and Cons of Making the Census Bureau's American Community Survey Voluntary
." While the committee invited outside witnesses in favor of a mandatory ACS, the subcommittee chair and full committee chair, Trey Gowdy (R-SC) and Darrell Issa (R-CA), were aggressive in their questioning.
Congressman Ted Poe (R-TX), sponsor of H.R. 931, a bill making ACS voluntary and the impetus for the hearing, was the only witness to
speak in favor
of a voluntary ACS. (Poe testimony starts at 2:10 of hearing
. There was no questioning of Congressman Poe.) The other witnesses were (click on their names for their testimony)
, Ph.D., Director, U.S. Census Bureau
, Ph.D., Resident Scholar, American Enterprise Institute
, Ph.D., Chief Economist, National Association of Realtors
, Vice President, Research, Greater Houston Partnership
Chairmen Gowdy and Issa both granted the importance of the ACS data. Noting that the right to vote - "the ultimate survey" - is not mandatory, Gowdy focused his questions on why some questions on the ACS were mandatory with possible punishment of going to jail. (See 44:05-49:20 and 54:43+ in the
Issa, in one line of questioning, asked why the private sector users of the data shouldn't be paying for the ACS data if it is so valuable. (See 1:05:50+) Issa then asked what he called his most important question, "Could money solve this problem statistically?" (referring to the fact that response rates to ACS survey would drop if ACS were made voluntary, thereby affecting data quality.)
Issa concluded his questioning (starting 1:15:13-1:17:45) by requesting draft ideas from Director Groves for how an ACS could eventually be phased to a voluntary survey while preserving the data quality.
At 1:11:57, Director Groves refers to the fact that Canada made their census long-form voluntary in 2010, implemented it in 2011 as the National Household Survey, and that Statistics Canada is still grappling with the implications for data quality.
The other Congressmen who attended the hearing were Subcommittee Ranking Member Danny Davis (D-IL), former Subcommittee Ranking Member (111th Congress) Patrick McHenry (R-MA), and 111th Congress Subcommittee Chair Lacy Clay (D-MO).
My summary here only begins to summarize the hearing. Please let me know your thoughts about the hearing in the Comment space below.
Besides the testimony linked above, much more information is available on the topic, including the following:
Director Groves' blog,
How America Knows How It’s Doing
20011 Census Bureau reports on 2003 research on voluntary ACS
from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and The International Council of Shopping Centers (ICSC) in support of ACS (in response to requests for comments on ACS continuation and possible enhancement.)
The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights
American Sociological Association
letters of concern for voluntary ACS submitted for the written record of the hearing.
The other materials for the written record of the hearing should soon be linked from this
under "Other Documents"
See how Target, the National Association of Home Builders, and Greater Houston Partnership use ACS data at these YouTube videos by the Census Bureau
Target and the American Community Survey
Target and Economic Statistics
Stats in Action: National Association of Home Builders Uses ACS Data
Stats in Action: Greater Houston Partnership Uses ACS Data
Wed, Mar 07, 2012 01:35 PM
Not Yet Rated
Copy and paste the link below into other web pages, documents, or email messages to allow immediate, permanent access to this page. Security settings will remain in place and login will be necessary for protected content.
March 30, 2012 4:18 pm
No Comments submitted.
Code of Conduct
Copyright © 2012 American Statistical Association. All Rights Reserved.
Powered by Higher Logic's Connected Community