ASA Connect

 View Only

Random and fixed models

  • 1.  Random and fixed models

    Posted 02-11-2016 11:30

    Hello

    I am new to hierarchical models and will be grateful for the tips.

    Here is some background info.

    The study question is: Is there a difference between and within hospitals in number of referrals to certain social services?

    Referral is coded as YES/NO (outcome). Individual characteristics are either kept as continuous  or as yes/no, similar with hospital characteristics. There are 53 hospitals grouped into 3 levels.

    I am running PROC GLIMMIX using the following code:

    /*Random effect of hospital*/

    PROC GLIMMIX Data=

    CLASS Hosp_Disch;

    MODEL referral (DESCENDING)=  WGTGRMS Sex /dist=binary link=logit ddfm=bw solution;

    random intercept/subject=Hosp_Disch  type=cs G;

    random _residual_/subject=Hosp_Disch ;

    Title 'GLIMMIX: Birth weight continuous plus NEWPLURAL and random effect of hospitals';

    /*Random and fixed effect of hospital*/

    PROC GLIMMIX Data=;

    CLASS Hosp_Disch  Hosp_Level;

    MODEL referral (DESCENDING)=  WGTGRMS NEWPLURAL Hosp_Level/dist=binary link=logit ddfm=bw solution;

    random intercept/subject=Hosp_Disch  type=cs G;

    random _residual_/subject=Hosp_Disch ;

    Title 'GLIMMIX: Birth weight continous plus NEWPLURAL and random/fixed effect of hospitals'; 

    Results from these two codes look exactly the same, and I do not have p-value for hospital variance. What am I missing?

    Gabi

    ------------------------------
    Gabriela Kernan
    Epidemiologist
    University of Massachussets Lowell
    ------------------------------